Clipped from: https://taxguru.in/income-tax/comprehensive-clause-by-clause-guide-tax-audit-form-3cd.html
Introduction
Form 3CD is the Statement of Particulars prescribed under Rule 6G(2) of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, to be furnished along with the Tax Audit Report (Form 3CA/3CB) under section 44AB of the Income-tax Act, 1961. It contains 44 clauses requiring granular disclosures on accounting methods, statutory compliances, allowances/disallowances, and specified transactions. This guide provides a professional, clause-by-clause analysis with corporate case studies, real-life examples and numerical illustrations. Where relevant, drafting tips and sample qualification language are included to strengthen documentation and reporting discipline.
How to Use This Guide
For each clause, the following sub-structure is followed: (a) What to Report & Statutory Basis; (b) Key Definitions & Scope; (c) Typical Audit Procedures & Evidence; (d) Corporate Case Study; (e) Numerical Illustration; (f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls; (g) Sample Qualification Language (where required).
PART A — Basic Particulars (Clauses 1 to 8)
Clause 1: Name, Address and Identification (Name, Address, PAN/Aadhaar)
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report the legal name as per PAN database, principal address registered for income tax, and PAN or Aadhaar (as applicable). For non-residents without Aadhaar, PAN is mandatory. Cross-verify with master data and certificate of incorporation/partnership deed.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: ‘Assessee’ under s.2(7) covers all persons chargeable to tax. ‘Principal place of business’ is where central management or predominant operations occur. Disclose trade name if different from legal name.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Obtain PAN allotment letter, MCA master data, GST registration certificate, board resolution for name change, and verify consistency across ITR, GST and financial statements.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A Jaipur-based NBFC used a trade name in invoices while its legal name changed post-merger. Non-alignment caused portal validation errors during e-filing. Auditor ensured Form 3CD reflected the new legal name exactly as per MCA and PAN, with the erstwhile name mentioned in notes.
(e) Numerical Illustration: None—disclosure clause. However, mismatches may delay uploading. Keep exact spacing/capitalisation as per PAN database.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Ensure address includes PIN code; update if registered office shifted. Where multiple units exist, mention principal address in Part A and list other addresses in Clause 11 (books) as applicable.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: If legal name and PAN database not aligned: “We note that legal name as per MCA differs from the name auto-populated from PAN. Reconciliation furnished by management has been obtained; e-filing validation accepted the updated name.”
Clause 2: Liability to Tax Audit u/s 44AB
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: State whether the assessee is liable for tax audit and the relevant clause of section 44AB (a–e).
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Turnover/ gross receipts to be determined as per Guidance Note on Tax Audit (ICAI). For presumptive regimes (44AD/44ADA/44AE), audit triggers on lower profit declarations or turnover thresholds.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Compute turnover including GST as per ICAI GN where contract terms are tax-inclusive; exclude GST when collected as agent. Consider s.44AB(e) for specified professionals if gross receipts exceed threshold.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A mid-sized engineering contractor (turnover ₹9.4 crore, GST included) argued no audit since taxable value was ₹8 crore. Contract was tax-inclusive; thus turnover for s.44AB includes GST. Audit applicable.
(e) Numerical Illustration: If turnover is ₹9.40 crore (inclusive GST 18%), taxable value ≈ ₹7.97 crore, GST ₹1.43 crore. For 44AB limit of ₹10 crore (cash receipts/payments ≤ 5% each), check cash ratios before concluding.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Evaluate multiple businesses on aggregate basis. Keep working papers on turnover computation and cash receipt/payment percentages.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Assessee contends non-applicability of s.44AB based on alternative turnover computation. In our view, audit is applicable; report is accordingly furnished under s.44AB(a).”
Clause 3: Status (Company/Firm/LLP/Proprietor/Local Authority/Trust)
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report legal status for the previous year. Any change during the year must be described.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: ‘Status’ determines rates and certain provisions (e.g., s.40(b) for firms, MAT/AMT).
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Inspect incorporation documents, partnership deed (with profit-sharing ratios), registration certificates, and amendments.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A partnership converted to LLP on 1 January. Auditor reported firm status up to conversion and LLP thereafter; addressed implications under s.170 (succession).
(e) Numerical Illustration: Not numerical per se; but disclose capital continuity and PAN migration data in working papers.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: If conversion/merger/demerger occurred, cross-link with Clause 9 (partners/members) and Clause 18 (depreciation block continuity).
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Status changed from partnership firm to LLP on 01-01-20XX; particulars are based on books maintained pre and post conversion.”
Clause 4: Previous Year and Assessment Year
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report the PY (financial year) and AY. For short PY (first/last year), disclose clearly.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Previous Year u/s 3; AY is PY+1. Short PYs occur on new business set-up or closure.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Verify board minutes for change of year-end (rare), and ensure consistency with financial statements.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A foreign company had a 9-month PY due to exit. Auditor disclosed short PY and addressed depreciation apportionment in Clause 18.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Example: PY 01-04-20XX to 31-12-20XX (9 months); adjust thresholds like TDS and turnover proportionately only where statute so provides (usually not).
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Mind due dates for audit upload. Tie-up with e-filing portal selections.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Books cover a short previous year of 9 months consequent to closure; reporting is for the said period.”
Clause 5: Indirect Tax Registrations (GST, Customs, Excise, etc.)
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report whether liable to pay indirect taxes and furnish GSTIN/other IDs.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Includes GST, Customs IEC, Professional Tax, etc. Focus on GSTIN(s) across States and SEZ units.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Obtain GST registration master, list of GSTINs for all States, SEZ/EOU approvals, IEC certificate.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A multi-State retailer had 15 GSTINs. Centralised accounting led to mis-posting of place-of-supply for 2 States. Auditor listed all GSTINs and flagged reconciliation in Clause 44.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Reconcile turnover as per books with aggregate GSTR-1/3B; differences to be explained in Clause 4/Clause 44 working papers.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Report all active registrations; mention surrendered numbers with effective date.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Management is in process of cancelling dormant GSTINs for closed locations; details based on registration master as on reporting date.”
Clause 6: Nature of Business/Profession and Changes
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report main nature of business/profession and any change during the year.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: ‘Change’ includes addition of a new line, hiving-off, or discontinuance of a major segment.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Review MoA objects, board resolutions, segment reporting (Ind AS 108/AS 17), and revenue disclosures.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A manufacturing company added D2C e-commerce. Change reported; impact analysed in Clause 32 (speculative/commodities) for hedging and Clause 31 (loans/advances).
(e) Numerical Illustration: Quantify revenue mix pre/post change (e.g., Manufacturing ₹120 cr → ₹100 cr; E‑commerce ₹0 → ₹25 cr).
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Describe changes succinctly; avoid marketing jargon. Tie with Clause 11(b) for inventory valuation if new segment carries different costing.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “During the year, the assessee commenced online retailing; the same is reported as change in nature.”
Clause 7: Books of Account – List & Locations
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: List books of account and locations (HO/branches/warehouses) where maintained; include ERP modules.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: ‘Books’ u/s 2(12A) include ledgers, journals, vouchers, and electronic records.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Obtain chart of accounts, ERP access paths, branch address list, and inventory system details.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A bank-channel finance NBFC kept loan origination data on a third‑party platform; auditor recorded that as a location of books and obtained read-only logs.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Map number of locations (e.g., 1 HO + 8 branches + 3 warehouses).
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Mention cloud/SaaS systems explicitly (e.g., AWS region, vendor).
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Books are maintained on SAP S/4HANA hosted on cloud; branch sales are recorded centrally. Addresses of warehouses are listed.”
Clause 8: Presumptive Taxation Sections, if opted
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: State whether sections 44AD/44ADA/44AE/44B/44BB/44BBA/44BBB etc. are applicable/opted and give particulars.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Covers presumptive profit provisions for small businesses, professionals, transporters, shipping, oil exploration, foreign construction, etc.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Verify declarations, eligibility conditions, cash receipts percentages (44AD), carried-forward implications.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A small architect shifted from 44ADA to normal provisions mid-year to claim high actual expenses; auditor reported the switch and warned about 5-year lock-in under 44AD (not for 44ADA).
(e) Numerical Illustration: Transporter owning 8 goods carriages under 44AE: Income per vehicle as per prescribed limits; compute accordingly and cross-link to Clause 18 for depreciation eligibility.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Ensure that opting out triggers audit if profits lower than presumptive minima, subject to turnover. Maintain evidence of ownership count for 44AE.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Assessee has reported income u/s 44AE; particulars are based on vehicle-wise statement and RC copies verified on sample basis.”
Clause 9: Special Focus Area – Partners/Members details; profit-sharing; changes during the year (for firms/AOP/LLP).
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 10: Special Focus Area – Nature of business/profession changes—already covered in Clause 6; here, disclosures specific to change events and dates.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 11: Method of Accounting and ICDS Compliance
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: State the method of accounting (mercantile/cash), any change, and whether income is computed per s.145 and ICDS. Quantify effect of deviations/change.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: ICDS notified u/s 145(2) apply for computation (not for book accounting). Any deviation/adjustment must be disclosed standard-wise.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Obtain accounting policy note; reconcile ICDS adjustments (e.g., forex, construction, government grants). Prepare standard-wise working with impact on profit.
(d) Corporate Case Study: An EPC contractor recognised revenue using Ind AS 115. ICDS III (construction contracts) led to additional ₹1.20 crore income due to percentage-of-completion differences.
(e) Numerical Illustration: If book profit shows revenue ₹100.00 crore while ICDS adds ₹1.20 crore, taxable business income increases by ₹1.20 crore; create memorandum entries and MAT reconciliation.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Maintain an ICDS computation sheet; map to Clause 13(d)/(e) standard-wise adjustments.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “ICDS computations are based on management workings; due to system constraints, we performed analytical procedures and test checks.”
Clause 12: Valuation of Closing Stock and s.145A Adjustments
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report the method of valuation of closing stock (including WIP) and any change along with effect on profit. Consider inclusive method per s.145A for taxes, cess, etc.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Cost or NRV, whichever lower, as per AS 2 / Ind AS 2. For manufacturers, include appropriate overheads; for service WIP, use cost-based measures.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Review costing sheets, overhead absorption rates, and compare NRV to cost. Verify inclusion/exclusion of duties and GST per statute and ICDS II.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A pharma company excluded freight-in and manufacturing overheads from WIP, understating stock by ₹2.4 crore. Auditor quantified and reported effect.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Closing stock as per books ₹18.6 cr; correct valuation ₹21.0 cr → understatement ₹2.4 cr; profit should increase by ₹2.4 cr; tax @ 25% ≈ ₹0.60 cr.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Ensure consistency of formulas in ERP; examine negative stocks; roll-forward test for WIP completion %.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Due to limitations in capturing standard costs, valuation difference is computed on sampling and management estimates.”
Clause 13: Capital Asset Converted into Stock‑in‑Trade (s.45(2)/28)
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars where capital asset is converted to stock‑in‑trade. Fair market value on conversion is deemed full value of consideration for capital gains; business income arises on sale.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Two‑stage tax: (i) capital gains up to date of conversion; (ii) business profit on sale over FMV at conversion.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Verify board approval, valuation report, and inventory entry. Trace subsequent sale invoices.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A real estate developer converted an investment land into stock‑in‑trade. FMV on conversion ₹12 cr (indexed cost ₹5 cr); later sold at ₹14 cr.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Capital gains: ₹12 − ₹5 = ₹7 cr (year of sale). Business income: ₹14 − ₹12 = ₹2 cr (year of sale).
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Time the conversion carefully; ensure FMV basis is defensible (registered valuer report).
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “FMV adopted is based on registered valuer’s report; no independent valuation performed by us.”
Clause 14: Items Not Credited to P&L but Taxable
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report items like escalation claims, export incentives, interest on income-tax refund, etc., not credited to P&L though taxable.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Accrual under ICDS IV; taxation independent of book recognition.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Scrutinise other ledgers, legal claim trackers, bank advices; compare with GST/Customs ICEGATE data for incentives.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Company received duty drawback ₹0.85 cr post year-end for exports made; income had accrued earlier per scheme conditions.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Accrued incentive ₹0.85 cr added to taxable income; MAT unaffected if not in books—reconcile in Clause 22 (MAT) working.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Scan ‘suspense/clearing’ accounts for credits. Review board notes for claims lodged.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Recognition of export incentive is based on eligibility conditions satisfied; exact sanction pending at year-end.”
Clause 15: Depreciation (Block-wise) u/s 32
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Give details of additions/deletions, rate-wise blocks, put‑to‑use dates, and depreciation amount including extra shift/additional depreciation where applicable.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Block concept; half-rate for assets put to use <180 days. Additional depreciation for manufacturing/ specified sectors.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Verify FA register, GRNs, CWIP capitalisation, asset tags, and sale deeds. Cross-check GST ITC on capital goods vis‑à‑vis capitalization.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A textile unit acquired new plant ₹20 cr on 1 Oct; additional depreciation @20% available (if eligible) prorated. Part sold during year for ₹2 cr; block remains as WDV positive.
(e) Numerical Illustration: WDV opening ₹30 cr + additions ₹20 cr − sale consideration (limited to WDV) ₹2 cr = ₹48 cr; normal dep @15% half-year on additions, full on opening; compute and disclose.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Watch for ROUs (Ind AS 116) and their tax depreciation—clarify policy adopted. Componentisation in books doesn’t affect block rates.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Depreciation is based on management’s put‑to‑use certifications; physical verification performed on sample basis.”
Clause 16: Disallowances under Sections 40/40A/40(a)(ia) and 36(1)(va)
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report inadmissible expenses: TDS defaults (resident/non‑resident), cash payments > limits, gratuity provisions, employee PF/ESI delays, etc.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Employee contribution u/s 36(1)(va) is disallowed if paid beyond due date under respective law; employer’s share governed by s.43B.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Obtain expense ledgers, TDS returns (26Q/27Q), PF/ESI challans, cash book analysis, payroll reconciliations.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A logistics company paid employee ESI for March on 25th of next month beyond statutory due date (say 15th); ₹18 lakh disallowed u/s 36(1)(va).
(e) Numerical Illustration: (‘TDS short-deduction ₹12 lakh on contractor payments triggers disallowance u/s 40(a)(ia) @30% of such sum where applicable.’,)
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: (‘Reconcile Clause 34 TDS data; link with GSTR‑2B for vendor payments to detect service items missed for TDS.’,)
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “Disallowances computed from management statement; we performed test checks including tracing of specific samples to challans and 26AS.”
Clause 17: Disallowances u/s 43B (Including MSME Clause)
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report liabilities allowable on payment basis (tax, duty, bonus, leave encashment*) and payments to micro/small enterprises beyond timelines under MSMED Act [s.43B(h)].
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: For 43B(h), payments to micro and small (not medium) within agreed date (max 45 days) or 15 days if no written agreement; otherwise disallowed.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Obtain MSME declarations from vendors as at year-end; age payable listing; payment terms; compute delays.
(d) Corporate Case Study: A consumer goods company owed ₹4.2 cr to registered micro units; ₹1.1 cr crossed 45 days outstanding as on balance sheet date—disallowance u/s 43B(h).
(e) Numerical Illustration: (‘If ₹1.1 cr paid after year-end, deduction allowed in year of payment; ensure books vs. tax reconciliation reflects this.’,)
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: (‘Vendor classification must be frozen before year-end; absence of declarations is a risk—treat such vendors as non‑MSME unless evidence exists.’,)
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “MSME status is based on vendor self‑declarations; where unavailable, the assessee has treated vendors as non‑MSME.”
Clause 18: Deemed Incomes (s.41, etc.)
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: (‘Report remission/cessation of liabilities, recovery of bad debts written off, and other deemed incomes.’,)
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: (‘s.41(1) applies when an earlier allowed deduction is later recovered or liability ceases.’,)
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: (‘Scan credit balances written back, legal confirmations, and settlements.’,)
(d) Corporate Case Study: (‘Old creditor ₹0.75 cr untraceable; company wrote back after legal notices—taxable u/s 41(1).’,)
(e) Numerical Illustration: (‘Write-back ₹0.75 cr increases PGBP; MAT also applies as it is credited to P&L.’,)
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: (‘Distinguish genuine settlements vs. unilateral write-back without evidence.’,)
(g) Sample Qualification Language: “We relied on management’s legal memos regarding cessation; confirmations were not available for all creditors.”
Clause 19: Special Focus Area – Gifts/Non-business receipts taxable u/s 56(2)(x); share premium issues vis‑à‑vis s.56(2)(viib) (for closely-held companies).
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 20: Special Focus Area – Section 69/69C/69D related reporting where entries exist in books (if any); loans/borrowings via hundis etc.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 21: Special Focus Area – Loans and deposits u/s 269SS/269T; particulars of contraventions and repayments; mode of receipt/payment.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 22: Special Focus Area – MAT/AMT details (115JB/115JC) where applicable; credit u/s 115JAA/115JD—reconciliations.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 23: Special Focus Area – Transfer pricing—Specimen reference to s.92E where applicable; disclosures of domestic transactions u/s 92BA (if any).
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 24: Special Focus Area – Goods/Services traded under speculative category u/s 43(5); derivatives, commodity trades; forex transactions.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 25: Special Focus Area – Amounts received/paid in cash above thresholds; cash receipts for sale of goods/services u/s 269ST; cash payments u/s 40A(3).
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 26: Special Focus Area – Section 32AC/32AD/32ABA/35AD etc.—deductions for capital investments/specified businesses; validity conditions.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 27: Special Focus Area – CENVAT/GST refunds, duty drawbacks and export incentives; timing of recognition vis‑à‑vis ICDS IV.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 28: Special Focus Area – Details of income chargeable u/s 115BBE, winnings, lotteries, etc., if any.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 29: Special Focus Area – Section 33AB/33ABA/35/35(2AB) scientific research; approvals, agreements and usage.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 30: Special Focus Area – Payments to persons specified u/s 40A(2)(b); related party matrices and benchmarking.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 31: Special Focus Area – Borrowings and repayments; interest capitalization (s.36(1)(iii)), thin capitalization (94B) for certain entities.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 32: Special Focus Area – Professional/technical fees and TDS u/ss 194J/194C/195; linkage to 40(a)(i)/(ia).
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 33: Special Focus Area – Quantitative details of principal items of goods traded/manufactured; yield, waste, shortages.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 34: Special Focus Area – Details of turnover, gross profit, and ratios; unusual fluctuations with reasons.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 35: Special Focus Area – Costs covered under Ind AS/AS; provisioning policies; ECL for NBFCs; impairment.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 36: Special Focus Area – Dividend distribution and s.2(22)(e) deemed dividend exposure in closely-held companies.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 37: Special Focus Area – CSR expenditure u/s 37 Explanation 2; capital vs revenue classification; 80G eligibility of implementing agencies.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 38: Special Focus Area – Unrecorded income/expenditure discovered in survey/search and its treatment in books and tax audit.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 39: Special Focus Area – Demand/refund under other laws and its accounting; contingent vs. recognized assets/liabilities.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 40: Special Focus Area – Details of expenditure by categories subject to TDS and their compliance status.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 41: Special Focus Area – Details of turnover reported in GST vis‑à‑vis books; reconciliations and reasons (also see Clause 44).
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 42: Special Focus Area – Trading in virtual digital assets (VDAs)/crypto; TDS u/s 194S; tax u/s 115BBH.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 43: Special Focus Area – SFT reportable transactions cross-check; high-value cash/credit card/FDRs; AIR mismatches.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Clause 44: Special Focus Area – Break-up of total expenditure into payment modes: cash, bank, other—percentages and analysis.
(a) What to Report & Statutory Basis: Report particulars as required by the clause, capturing scope, thresholds and any quantitative impacts. Where not applicable, state NIL and retain evidence.
(b) Key Definitions & Scope: Define all terms used in the clause referencing the Income‑tax Act/Rules, ICDS and applicable circulars.
(c) Audit Procedures & Evidence: Lay down a checklist-driven procedure: ledger scrutiny, external reconciliations (GST, MCA, banks), management representations, and sampling.
(d) Corporate Case Study: Illustrative corporate scenario drafted to mirror the clause—highlighting grey areas and auditor judgement.
(e) Numerical Illustration: Provide a computation or reconciliation demonstrating the monetary impact under the clause.
(f) Reporting Tips & Common Pitfalls: Cross-link to related clauses to keep one source of truth; ensure arithmetic ties to financial statements and tax computations.
(g) Sample Qualification Language: Provide short, precise language indicating basis of reporting, reliance on representations where appropriate, and any limitations.
Drafting Qualified/Emphasis Paragraphs Referencing 3CD Clauses
When the auditor concludes that a material misstatement or limitation exists in information required by a clause, the matter should be (i) reported in the specific clause in Form 3CD and (ii) cross‑referenced in the main audit report (Form 3CA/3CB) through a ‘Basis for Qualified Opinion’ or ‘Emphasis of Matter’, as appropriate. Samples:
ICDS Adjustments (Clause 11/13)
“The Company has not maintained standard‑wise ICDS computations. Consequently, we were unable to determine the effects, if any, on revenue recognition and valuation of inventories. Subject to this, the particulars in Clauses 11 and 12 are reported based on management workings and alternative procedures performed by us.”
MSME Delays (Clause 17 – s.43B(h))
“Based on vendor declarations available, certain dues to micro and small enterprises remained outstanding for a period exceeding the prescribed timelines. The resultant disallowance under section 43B(h) has been quantified by management at ₹1.10 crore and reported in Clause 17. We have performed test checks on the ageing and terms.”
Employee Contributions (Clause 16 – s.36(1)(va))
“Employee contributions to PF/ESI aggregating ₹18.00 lakh were deposited after the due dates under the respective Acts; accordingly, the sums are disallowable. The tax impact has been considered by management in the return of income.”
Integrated Corporate Case Studies
Case Study A – Manufacturing Conglomerate (Ind AS)
Background: A Jaipur-based listed manufacturing conglomerate with turnover ₹1,250 crore operates across appliances and consumer durables. Key issues: ICDS vs Ind AS adjustments (Clause 11/12), MSME delays (Clause 17), related party payments (Clause 30), speculative commodity hedges (Clause 24), and GST–books reconciliation (Clause 41/44). Outcome: Additional taxable income of ₹7.6 crore from ICDS/valuation adjustments; disallowance u/s 43B(h) ₹1.1 crore; improvements in vendor master governance.
Case Study B – NBFC (EIR, ECL & TDS)
Background: An NBFC with AUM ₹900 crore follows Ind AS 109. Audit focus on EIR-based revenue, ECL provisioning, and TDS on broker/technical fees. Outcome: Clause 16 disallowance for late employee contributions ₹0.22 crore; Clause 40 TDS reconciliation corrected short‑deduction on commission; Clause 15 addressed ROU vs tax depreciation policy.
Case Study C – EPC Contractor (Construction)
Background: A large EPC contractor recognised revenue under Ind AS 115 with multiple performance obligations. ICDS III required separate POC computation. Inventory WIP undercounted site overheads. Outcome: Clause 11 increased taxable income by ₹1.20 crore; Clause 12 added ₹2.40 crore; Clause 33 quantitative reconciliation improved wastage controls.
Numerical Illustrations – Selected Clauses
Clause 15 – Depreciation (Block 15%)
Opening WDV ₹30.00 cr; additions 01-Oct ₹20.00 cr; sale consideration ₹2.00 cr.
Depreciation: Opening 30.00 × 15% = 4.50; Additions half‑year: 20.00 × 15% × 50% = 1.50; Total = ₹6.00 cr. Closing WDV = 30+20−2−6 = ₹42.00 cr.
Clause 16 – 40(a)(ia) Disallowance
Contractor charges ₹4.00 cr with TDS required @1%. Deducted ₹2.5 lakh short. Disallowance @30% on short‑deducted base ₹2.5 cr? If short-deduction pertains to rate differential on entire ₹4 cr, compute per jurisprudence; conservative approach disallows proportionate ₹0.75 cr.
Clause 17 – 43B(h) MSME
MSME dues ₹4.20 cr; overdue beyond 45 days as on B/S date ₹1.10 cr → disallowed in PY; allowed in year of actual payment.
Governance, Materiality and Documentation
Maintain a clause-wise working paper index mapping each disclosure to evidence. Quantify materiality benchmarks and apply analytical procedures. Capture management representations for grey areas (ICDS, MSME status, related parties). Reconcile Form 3CD totals to tax computation and return schedules to ensure one consistent story.
Conclusion
Form 3CD is a high-stakes compliance statement. A rigorous clause-by-clause approach—grounded in definitions, reconciliations, controls testing, and precise drafting—reduces litigation and enhances reliability of the return of income. This guide equips Chartered Accountants to deliver defensible, value-adding tax audits across industries, including manufacturing, EPC, services, and financial services sectors.
aniltikotekar4sme.com 