Farm sector on the boil: How Modi-led NDA government lost sight of the agricultural sector–Financial Express–18.06.2017

  1. The governments cannot be  blamed for the occurrence of drought, but governments are solely responsible for the mismanagement of the consequences of drought.
  2. Apart from the natural calamity of drought, there were man-made calamities, and this column is about how the two have brought about the explosive situation in the country.
  3. The bulk of farmers in India have no choice but to do farming. Land is the only asset they have, farming is the only skill they possess, and unless they grow food many of them will face starvation.
  4. Agriculture, despite its declining share in total output (GDP), is also the largest employer. In India’s economy, the agriculture sector has primacy.
  5. government erred grievously on the issue of minimum support prices (MSP).
  6. it dealt a body blow to farmers by denying them even a reasonable increase in MSP in its first three years.
  7. The ostensible reason for denying a fair MSP was that higher MSP fueled inflation, which is partly true, but to lean in favour of inflation control against the interest of India’s farmer-producers was the height of folly.
  8. Some inflation is inevitable, and the government and the RBI must use other instruments to moderate inflation rather than reduce the farming community to penury.
  9. The second grave error was demonetisation. Mr Harish Damodaran has convincingly demonstrated how demonetisation has crippled the post-harvest agricultural economy (see The Crops of Wrath, Indian Express, June 12, 2017).
  10. Agricultural products are bought and sold largely in cash. Demonetisation dried up liquidity and prices have crashed. According to Mr Damodaran, never before have prices of tomato, potato and onion crashed at the same time. Same is the situation with soyabean, arhar, garlic, methi (fenugreek) and grapes. Saying that farmers have resorted to ‘fire sales’, Mr Damodaran’s conclusion is, “We have entered deflation territory in farm produce, whose proximate trigger clearly has been demonetisation.”
  11. The third error was when the Prime Minister announced, on behalf of the yet-to-be-elected Uttar Pradesh government, that all farm loans in UP will be waived if the BJP formed the government.
  12. More likely, it was just an election promise in a state that the BJP perhaps did not expect to win, but it was an unequivocal promise that has returned to haunt the BJP in several states.
  13. Farm loan waivers are neither intrinsically ‘good’ nor ‘bad’. As Dr MS Swaminathan said a few days ago, “Loan waivers, though temporarily necessary, do not provide for a secure long term credit system” (emphasis supplied). When farmers do not get a fair and reasonable price and are unable to repay their loans, they demand a loan waiver. The holder of the highest political office promised a total loan waiver, why blame the farmers for demanding that the promise be implemented?
  14. Jobless youth angry—The last straw was jobless growth. Young men can find no work on farms or off farms. Micro, small and medium businesses are not offering new jobs. Tier 2, 3 and 4 towns are full of jobless youth and their anger has turned against the central government.


via Farm sector on the boil: How Modi-led NDA government lost sight of the agricultural sector – The Financial Express

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s