If an unauthorised transaction takes place from your bank account, who is liable for the loss – you or the bank? Something similar happened with Ms Varsha, a resident of New Delhi’s East of Kailash area, who decided not to sit quietly and filed a case against her bank. She finally won relief in the Consumer Commission on October 30, 2026.
The case dates back to 2016, when Ms Varsha lost Rs 77,114 from her Canara Bank account to 3 unauthorised online transactions, without her knowledge. Ms Varsha claimed that she didn’t receive any message as she was facing issues with her mobile.
She then alleged that upon getting the delayed debit alerts, she immediately reported the same to Canara Bank. Alleging the bank’s deficiency in service, Ms Varsha prayed for a refund of Rs 2,28,839 with 18% interest, ECS charges, revival penalties, and compensation for mental agony and litigation costs of Rs 25,000.
While Canara Bank stated that the leakage of OTP and the card details is the responsibility of the cardholder, Delhi Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission sided with the lady. Here’s how she won the case against Canara Bank.
Woman says money deducted from account, bank told to refund
Ms Varsha said that on 04.07.2016, 05.07.2016, and 09.07.2016, unauthorised online transactions totaling Rs 77,114 were debited from her account. Because she was facing an issue with her mobile then, Ms Varsha claimed she was unable to access the internet.
It is alleged that she did not receive any SMS when the transactions happened. Ms Varsha, however, shared that she got a delayed SMS notification on 10.07.2017, which she immediately reported to Canara Bank, requesting a block on all transactions in her account.
She also lodged a police complaint with PS Hazrat Nizamuddin.
Ms Varsha alleged that due to the unauthorised transactions, ECS penalty charges were debited by the lender, failure of mutual fund investments, and the lapse of her Life Insurance policy, which was later revived after paying penalty charges.
Because the bank did not refund the money lost in the unauthorised transactions, she issued a legal notice dated 02.05.2018.
What did the bank say on this?
In its reply to the commission, Canara Bank said it “is not responsible for transfer of funds on 04.07.2016, 05.07.2016 and 09.07.2016 to any third party”. It further added that the OTPs were not received by the user as her mobile was not working.
“The leakage of OTP and the card details is the responsibility of the card holder,” the bank stated, and prayed for dismissal of the complaint.
ET Wealth Online reached out to Canara Bank for a response regarding this case. However, the bank is yet to respond.
What did the Consumer Commission rule?
After having gone through the pleadings and documents on record, the Consumder Commission cited Ms Varsha’s email dated 10.07.2016, in which she had sent the details of fraudulent transactions made on 4th, 5th and 9th of July.
“Rs 5,000 was used for unauthorised transaction on 04.07.2016, Rs 2,000 on 05.07.2016 and Rs 70,084 on 09.07.2016.”
The commission cited the RBI Circular titled ‘Customer Protection-Limiting Liability of Customers in Unauthorized Electronic Banking Transaction’, which says that a customer shall have zero liability if the unauthorised transaction takes place because of the bank’s fraud/negligence/deficiency or a third-party breach.
In a fight that lasted around 10 years, the Consumer Commission ruled in the lady’s favour as it found the bank deficient in service. The Commission ordered the bank to refund the amount the lady lost in the fraudulent transaction on 09.07.2016.
Canara Bank has been ordered to refund Rs 70,084 with 7% interest from the date of transaction till payment. Additionally, it has been directed to pay Ms Varsha Rs 20,000 towards compensation and Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses.
What worked in Ms Varsha’s case here?
Two factors worked decisively in her favour: prompt reporting and documentary evidence. Anuj Dave, Practice Head (Ahmedabad & Mumbai) at Clavius Legal, told ET Wealth Online that not only did she inform the bank about the unauthorised transactions on 10 July 2016, but she also lodged a police complaint and produced documentary evidence.
On the other hand, although Canara Bank alleged that the customer’s banking credentials had been compromised, it failed to produce documentary evidence establishing negligence on her part.
“The fundamental legal principle is that a bank cannot escape liability merely by alleging that an OTP or banking credentials were compromised. Under the RBI’s customer-protection framework relied upon in the order, the burden of establishing customer liability rests on the bank,” Dave said.
Why was only Rs 70,084 awarded when she claimed a compensation of over Rs 2.28 lakh?
The Commission directed the bank to refund Rs 70,084, representing the unauthorised transactions dated 9 July 2016. Additionally, it awarded Rs 20,000 towards compensation and Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses.
Dave pointed out that the total monetary relief is substantially higher than the principal refund.
As regards the larger monetary claim, consequential losses such as ECS penalties, disrupted investments and insurance revival charges ordinarily require documentary evidence establishing the losses and their connection with the deficiency in banking services.
How quickly should you report a fraud transaction to get your money back?
It goes without saying that the reporting should be done immediately upon discovery! Preferably, the same should be done through the bank’s official reporting channels so there is a verifiable record of the complaint.
Under the RBI circular dated 6 July 2017, where an unauthorised transaction results from a third-party breach and neither the bank nor the customer is responsible, the customer has zero liability if the bank is notified within three working days of receiving its transaction alert.
Importantly, where the loss arises from fraud, negligence or deficiency attributable to the bank itself, the customer’s liability remains zero irrespective of the reporting timeline.
As a practical safeguard, consumers should immediately notify their bank, block the affected card or payment instrument, report the incident through the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal or helpline 1930, and preserve transaction alerts, complaint acknowledgements and all correspondence.