Can a self-acquired property become joint family property? Know why the property owner’s intention matters in such cases

Read more at:
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/wealth/legal/will/can-a-self-acquired-property-become-joint-family-property-know-why-the-property-owners-intention-matters-in-such-cases/articleshow/136014888.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/wealth/legal/will/can-a-self-acquired-property-become-joint-family-property-know-why-the-property-owners-intention-matters-in-such-cases/articleshow/136014888.cms

When the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 was enacted, the law mandated that all life interest of woman in a property is to be converted into absolute ownership. But for this provision (Section 14(1)) to apply the property first had to given to the woman for the limited purpose of her maintenance and well-being. If the property itself was given to her as a caretaker for the future legal heirs then the property is joint property.

This is how a grandaughter lost her case for 2.5 acre land in Madras High Court.

This land originally belonged to Mr Arunachala Chetty. On November 10, 1953, he executed a Will in favour of his wife (Smt Unnamalaiammal), giving her a life interest in this land but with the express condition that she couldn’t sell or give this land away, as it would ultimately go to his son Veerappan.

The only reason Arunachala Chetty did not leave the land directly to Veerappan was because Veerappan was young and lacked a sense of responsibility. As Veerapppan became an adult, he married twice and had five children in his lifetime.

But when it came to the question of who gets this 2.5- acre land, Veerappan and his mother (Smt Unnamalaiammal) together signed a gift settlement deed on February 26, 1975, and gave it to Smt Ganga (Veerappan’s second wife).

Ten years after Veerappan died, Ganga sold this 2.5- acre land to an outsider in 1996. Seeing this, Smt Kalaiselvi, Veerappan’s daughter from the first wife, got angry and demanded her share in this land as she thought that her step mother (Ganga) had no right to sell their land which she believed was ancestral land ).

Kalaiselvi lost the case in the Madras High Court on September 8, 2026. The court held that this land was not ancestral but rather a self-acquired property and therefore,under Hindu law, Veerappan and his mother could legally sign the gift settlement deed giving the land to Ganga who in turn sold it. The court said Section 14(2) of Hindu Succession Act, 1956 applied here.

Also read: Father sells 1,800 sq ft of ancestral land despite son’s objection; Supreme Court says son has no right to his exclusive share

Keep reading to know what does the Hindu law says about sons’ and daughters’ inheritance rights.

A self acquired property can also become joint family property in these cases

Rajani Tandale, Partner at 1 Finance, said to ET Wealth Online: A person who owns self-acquired property has complete freedom to decide how it passes after his death, including the character in which the beneficiary will hold it. In the case of C.N. Arunachala Mudaliar vs C.A. Muruganatha Mudaliar (1953), the Supreme Court said that a son does not hold property as ancestral merely because it came to him from his father. What matters is what the father’s intended.

For example your father has written a Will and you alone stand to get the property due to this Will, so in this case this property becomes your separate property. If the Will shows the property is meant for the son and his branch of the family, it becomes joint family (HUF) property in his hands, and his children acquire rights in it by birth.

The default works against the HUF, though. Tandale says that in cases where the Will is silent or vague, courts today usually treat the property as the beneficiary’s separate property.

The Madras High Court had cited a judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the C.N.Arunachala Mudaliar -vs- C.A.Muruganatha Mudaliar case, reported in AIR 1953 SC 495, and said that in this judgement, the Supreme Court held that the nature of properties bequeathed under a Will in the hands of the beneficiary thereunder depended on the intention of the testator.

The Supreme Court said this meant that if the bequest was intended for absolute enjoyment of the beneficiary, then it would be a separate property in the hands of the beneficiary. O n the other hand, if the testator’s intention was to partition the property or leave the property for the benefit of not just the beneficiary but his branch as well, then the property would be a joint family property in the hands of the beneficiary.

Also read: First husband’s family lost 45 bigha ancestral land case to late wife’s children from her second marriage; Supreme Court order explained

Choose the words of Will carefully to define the nature of the property

Tandale says that you should choose the words for describing a property and clearly state your intention in the Will so that later it can be clearly established that the property is intended to be as a joint family property or separate property. Here’s some practical tips:

  • State the character in plain words: When you are drafting a Will for your own separate property then you should write in the Will that the beneficiary of this Will will absolutely get this property as his separate property with full rights to sell, gift, mortgage or bequeath it. However, if you want the benefificary to get a joint family property, then write that this property is going to the beneficiary with respect to his status as Karta of the family and for the benefit of Hindu Undivided Family including his children and descendants, who shall have rights in this specific property by birth. Also remember that while drafting the Will you should avoid loose phrases like “to my son and his family” or “for his enjoyment.”
  • Don’t contradict yourself: If you are giving the absolute rights to your then don’t write that the beneficiary can’t sell it as this creates confusion and may even be challenged later. If your aim is to keep your property within the family, use the word HUF, joint family property, etc.
  • Record the background: Describe each property precisely and mention that it is your self-acquired property and how you acquired it. A line explaining why you are giving it in a particular way helps a court understand your intention.
  • Execute it properly: Use two independent witnesses, preferably not beneficiaries, and register the Will. Registration is not compulsory, but it makes the Will much harder to challenge.

Does a son have a right in his father’s ancestral land during the lifetime of his father?

Yogendra Aldak, Executive Partner, Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan Attorneys, explained to ET Wealth Online: “A Hindu father may leave his self-acquired property to whomever he chooses under Section 30 of the Hindu Succession Act, and a son has no right to object to being excluded.”

According to Aldak, where there is no W ill (intestate succession), the property passes under Section 8 to the Class I heirs: the widow, sons, daughters and the mother, each taking an equal share. The son’s share is his absolute property, held in his individual capacity and not as joint family property. That is the very principle the Supreme Court applied in a recent case J. Rajesh v. M. Kumaran. He may sell it or seek partition of it without reference to anyone else.

Leave a Reply