*****Food for thought-editorial in BusinessLine

https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/editorial/food-for-thought/article71715809.ece

At a recent event, Chief Economic Advisor V Anantha Nageswaran observed that “raising interest rates will not solve supply-induced problems”, and in fact, “it may even be counter-productive”. He argued that “fiscal and other public policy measures will be more important”. The CEA is broadly correct.

The underlying context is self-evident — with October headline inflation touching 6 per cent, the odds in favour of another rate hike, or set of hikes, have risen. The CEA may be worried that higher interest rates, while having little to do with restoring supplies of food, commodities or fuel, will merely hurt output by raising operating costs. This could lead to a stagflationary situation. To avert this prospect, the CEA seems to favour accommodative monetary and fiscal policies to support growth. A December 2023 Reserve Bank of India paper titled “‘Low Stagflation risk in India” explains: “While stagflation is usually a result of supply shocks such as a sudden spike in commodity prices, the risks could also propagate through knock-on effects through their impact on other macroeconomic variables such as a sudden depreciation of the exchange rate or a tightening of financial conditions (read higher interest rates).” Simply put, a combination of adverse exchange rate and higher interest rates could create stagflation, when commodity prices are high. India is faced with both food and fuel stress, the first on account of a deficient monsoon. In targeting inflation too hard there could be a growth sacrifice, with no guarantee that inflation will recede.

Fiscal policy can do better in stagflationary situations. Subsidies on fuel and fertilizer prices can soften the direct price impact. The trade-off in terms of a higher fiscal deficit is manageable, if interest costs do not climb. The CEA referred to the possibility of a higher fiscal deficit, while outlining the macro impact of the Iran war on India’s fundamentals before the House panel on finance. A combination of higher fiscal deficit and moderate interest rates (given the external sector constraints) is perhaps a better option today, than vice-versa.

However, the jury is still out on whether monetary policy should duck supply shocks. A December 2011 RBI paper by former Governor D Subbarao says: “The conventional wisdom is that if inflation expectations are well anchored, monetary policy need not react to supply shocks. This premise is based on the assumption that the supply shocks are purely temporary…So, the challenge for a central bank is to determine if the supply shock is temporary or permanent. If it is permanent, then the change in relative prices caused by it can result in higher general inflation.” A December 2024 RBI paper by Michael Debabrata Patra and others, makes a similar point on the impact of ‘persistent’ food inflation — that it can get ‘generalised’ through second order effects and higher price expectations. The RBI and Centre should act in tandem in view of these factors.

Published on November 18, 2026

Leave a Reply