A Gujarat-based firecracker trader who claimed that he had already declared his business income in an income-tax return filed under one PAN has got another opportunity to present his case after the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal set aside an assessment-related appellate order involving an addition of Rs 7.60 lakh.
The taxpayer, Vishnuprasad Gyarasilal Agrawal, had been allotted two Permanent Account Numbers due to an alleged clerical error. While he claimed to have disclosed his firecracker business income under one PAN, the Income Tax Department initiated reassessment proceedings using the other PAN and treated Rs 7.60 lakh as undisclosed income.
The taxpayer challenged the addition, arguing that the income had already been reported to the department and should not be taxed again merely because it was disclosed under a different PAN.
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal’s Ahmedabad Bench has now set aside the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals and sent the matter back to the Assessing Officer for a fresh assessment.
The Tribunal directed the Assessing Officer to give the taxpayer an opportunity to present his case and submit the relevant documents before passing a fresh order.
However, the ruling does not mean that the Rs 7.60 lakh addition has been deleted. The Tribunal has not decided whether the taxpayer’s claim of having already disclosed the income is correct. It has only directed the tax officer to reconsider the matter after hearing him.
How did the two-PAN issue lead to a Rs 7.60 lakh addition?
According to the ITAT order, Agrawal is an individual taxpayer engaged in the business of firecrackers, among other activities.
He had been allotted two PANs, ADWPA2173R and ABVPA8714F. The taxpayer claimed that the allotment of two PANs was the result of an inadvertent clerical error.
ALSO READ
For assessment year 2020-21, he had filed his income-tax return under PAN ABVPA8714F. He claimed that the entire income from his firecracker business had been disclosed in this return. An audit report had also been filed along with it.
However, the Income Tax Department initiated reassessment proceedings under Section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, using the other PAN, ADWPA2173R.
The Assessing Officer completed the reassessment on March 24, 2025, under Section 147 read with Section 144 of the Act and assessed income at Rs 7.60 lakh by making an addition of the same amount.
The taxpayer maintained that the department had overlooked the return already filed under the other PAN. He also claimed that the relevant taxes had already been paid or credited against the income disclosed in that return.
During the reassessment proceedings, he said he had submitted bank statements, confirmations of accounts from relevant parties, an affidavit requesting the deletion of the duplicate PAN and supporting documents showing the disclosure of business income under PAN ABVPA8714F.
Despite these submissions, the Assessing Officer proceeded with the addition.
Why did the first appeal fail?
Agrawal challenged the assessment before the Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals at the National Faceless Appeal Centre in Delhi.
However, he did not effectively participate in the appellate proceedings and failed to submit the required evidence and arguments before the authority.
The CIT Appeals order dated October 10, 2025, recorded that the taxpayer had failed to produce submissions or evidence despite being given several opportunities.
ALSO READ
The appellate authority observed that in the absence of supporting evidence, it had no reason to interfere with the assessment order.
It stated that it was constrained to agree with the approach adopted by the Assessing Officer and dismissed the taxpayer’s grounds of appeal.
This left the Rs 7.60 lakh addition intact, prompting the taxpayer to approach the ITAT Ahmedabad Bench.
Taxpayer also challenged Rs 2.80 lakh addition for unexplained expenditure
Apart from disputing the addition on the ground that the business income had already been declared under another PAN, the taxpayer raised another important issue concerning alleged unexplained expenditure.
In his grounds of appeal, he challenged an addition of Rs 2.80 lakh under Section 69C read with Section 115BBE of the Income-tax Act.
The addition related to alleged unexplained cash purchases. The taxpayer argued that the department had relied on loose papers, rojmel entries and a parallel set of accounts allegedly generated through software called MITI.
These documents were seized from a third party, M/s Ambica Ashish Tradelink LLP.
The taxpayer contended that the documents were not in his handwriting and did not carry his signature. He also argued that statements recorded from the partners and other persons associated with the searched entity had been used against him without supplying copies or giving him an opportunity to cross-examine those persons.
He further claimed that he had explained the source of the alleged purchases and submitted confirmations from relatives and associates aggregating Rs 1,16,125. According to him, these explanations were not properly considered by the lower authorities.
Another argument concerned the amount of purchases recorded by the Assessing Officer.
The taxpayer pointed out that the AO’s own findings recorded total purchases of only Rs 1,78,355 from the concerned party, of which Rs 50,000 had been made through banking channels.
He argued that an addition of Rs 2.80 lakh as unexplained expenditure was therefore higher than the total purchases recorded by the department.
ALSO READ
Alternatively, he argued that even if some purchases were found to be unaccounted, the department should consider taxing only the profit element embedded in those purchases rather than the entire purchase amount.
He also disputed the application of Section 115BBE, which provides for a higher tax rate on specified unexplained income.
These were the taxpayer’s arguments before the Tribunal. The ITAT did not give a separate ruling on the merits of these objections.
What did the ITAT say?
During the hearing before the Tribunal, the taxpayer’s authorised representative acknowledged that there had been no effective representation during the assessment proceedings or before the CIT Appeals.
The representative requested one more opportunity to present the taxpayer’s case before the Assessing Officer in the interest of justice.
The department’s representative, on the other hand, supported the orders passed by the lower authorities.
After hearing both sides and examining the available material, the Tribunal noted that the taxpayer had not effectively participated in the proceedings before the AO or the CIT Appeals.
However, it also took note of the taxpayer’s claim that the income had already been disclosed under the other PAN.
An important observation concerned the alleged cash purchases.
The Tribunal noted that the Assessing Officer had not recorded any finding that the cash purchases were not part of the taxpayer’s books of account.
Considering the overall circumstances, the Tribunal felt that the taxpayer deserved another opportunity to explain his case and submit the necessary evidence.
The order stated: “The interests of justice will be well served, if the Assessee be given an opportunity to present his case before the Ld. AO.”
Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside the order of the CIT Appeals and restored the matter to the file of the Assessing Officer.
What happens next?
The Assessing Officer will now have to conduct a fresh assessment after giving the taxpayer an opportunity to present his case.
The taxpayer has also been directed to submit all relevant materials and supporting documents to substantiate his claims. He will have to comply with notices issued by the tax authorities and avoid seeking unnecessary adjournments.
The Tribunal made it clear that the matter would be reconsidered by the AO rather than being decided in favour of the taxpayer outright.
For taxpayers facing assessment proceedings involving multiple PANs, the case highlights the importance of maintaining proper documentation to establish income disclosure and tax payments.
Mukul Saraswat, Partner at RPJ Associates, said: A taxpayer having more than one PAN does not, by itself, establish that income has escaped assessment or that the same income has been taxed twice. The actual return filed, income disclosed and taxes paid have to be examined before arriving at a conclusion.”
He added that “where a taxpayer claims that income has already been reported under another PAN, it is important to establish the claim through the original income-tax return, computation, audit report and tax-payment records. The taxpayer must also respond to notices and provide the necessary evidence during assessment proceedings.”
ITAT condones 100-day delay in filing appeal
There was also a delay in filing the appeal before the ITAT.
The Tribunal noted that the appeal was delayed by 100 days. After considering the delay affidavit submitted by the taxpayer, it found sufficient cause and condoned the delay.
The hearing was concluded on August 31, 2026, while the order was pronounced on October 30, 2026.
The Tribunal ultimately treated the taxpayer’s appeal as allowed for statistical purposes.
This means the taxpayer has secured another opportunity to contest the addition, but the final tax liability will depend on the fresh assessment by the Assessing Officer.
Disclaimer:
This article is based on the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Ahmedabad Bench, on October 30, 2026. The Tribunal has restored the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh assessment and has not deleted the tax addition or conclusively accepted the taxpayer’s claim.
Every financial journey has a turning point. What’s yours?
Financial Express is launching a new series highlighting real experiences with money, investments, and the taxman. Did a sudden tax rule catch you off guard? Did a piece of financial advice change your life? Your story could provide invaluable, practical lessons for thousands of fellow taxpayers. Share your experience with us. We respect your privacy: no stories will be featured without a direct conversation and your full consent. Thank you.