RBI argued that the Supreme Court’s decision went against international Basel banking rules on loss absorption. It also warned that restoring the bonds could put the interests of Yes Bank’s existing depositors at risk.
MUMBAI: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has warned that a Supreme Court decision overturning the write-off of bonds issued by troubled lender Yes Bank could weaken the country’s bank rescue framework, according to a court filing reviewed by Reuters.The case relates to Yes Bank’s rescue in 2020, when authorities wrote off Rs 8,415 crore worth of additional Tier-1 (AT1) bonds. These securities are designed to absorb losses when banks face financial distress.
Also Read: Relief for Chanda Kochhar as HC quashes ICICI Bank’s nod to prosecute ex-CEO in ‘loan fraud’ case
In a review petition filed on November 13, the RBI argued that the Supreme Court’s decision went against international Basel banking rules on loss absorption. It also warned that restoring the bonds could put the interests of Yes Bank’s existing depositors at risk.
The review petition is not publicly available. Neither the RBI nor Yes Bank immediately responded to Reuters’ requests for comment.
Last month, the Supreme Court declared the bond write-off illegal, citing procedural lapses, and directed that the securities be restored. However, review petitions filed by the RBI and Yes Bank have delayed relief for investors.
Also Read: IDBI Bank employee unions call nationwide strike on Dec 3 against proposed stake sale
The central bank maintained that writing down or converting AT1 bonds was a necessary part of India’s bank resolution framework. Allowing these securities to remain intact after a bank’s restructuring, it argued, would defeat their primary purpose of absorbing losses.
“The effect of the impugned judgment thus defeats the mandatory loss-absorption requirement of AT-1 Bonds and renders the relevant provisions of the Basel III Master Circular otiose,” the RBI said in its filing.
Basel rules are internationally recognised banking standards that prescribe capital requirements and safeguards to strengthen the financial system.
The RBI further argued that the court’s decision could affect future bank rescue efforts in India. It said existing regulations and the terms governing AT1 bonds required them to be written down, even if the restructuring plan did not specifically mention such a provision.
Restoring liabilities worth Rs 8,414 crore ($900.52 million) would reduce the value of capital contributed by the State Bank of India and other investors who participated in Yes Bank’s rescue, while also weakening safeguards for depositors, the RBI said.
The regulator also challenged the Supreme Court’s description of its role as that of a “mere bystander” during Yes Bank’s financial crisis.
It said it had repeatedly asked the lender to raise additional capital, appointed an additional director to its board and eventually stepped in when the bank became insolvent.