The Telangana High Court held that a final income tax assessment order passed without first issuing the mandatory draft assessment order under Section 144C(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is without jurisdiction.
Tecumseh Products India Private Limited (the petitioner) engaged in manufacturing compressors, filed a revised income tax return declaring nil income after adjusting its losses. Its case was selected for scrutiny and the Assessing Officer referred its international transactions to the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) for determining their arm’s length price.
The TPO proposed transfer pricing adjustments of Rs. 65,78,92,738. Although the TPO’s order stated that Section 144C had to be followed, the Assessing Officer issued a show cause notice and passed a final assessment order without first issuing a draft assessment order.
The petitioner’s counsel argued that issuing a draft assessment order was mandatory because the proposed adjustments arose from the TPO’s order. The petitioner’s counsel explained that this failure denied the company its statutory right to raise objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP).
The petitioner’s counsel further pointed out that the Income Tax Department’s portal provided only the option to appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) with no facility to approach the DRP.
The revenue counsel relied on the availability of a statutory appeal and argued that the writ petition was not maintainable.
The Division Bench comprising Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda observed that Section 144C provides eligible taxpayers an opportunity to challenge proposed adjustments before the DRP before the passing of a final assessment order.
The court observed
“The assessee thus gets the benefit of a review by a collegiate authority before any final order is made against it. That is a substantive right and not a procedural nicety.”
The court explained that Section 144B, which governs faceless assessments, does not replace the mandatory procedure under Section 144C.
The court further observed
“A show cause notice proposing a variation under the faceless scheme is not a draft order under Section 144C(1) and does not carry the same consequences.”
The court held that failure to issue a draft assessment order was a jurisdictional defect and not a minor procedural irregularity. It also rejected the objection based on the availability of an alternative remedy.
The court allowed the writ petition, set aside the final assessment order, demand notice and penalty directions and restored the proceedings to the stage following the TPO’s order.
Follow us on Telegram and WhatsApp for quick updates.
How to cite
2026 TAXSCAN (HC) 1862
Before the Court
Assistant Content Editor
Content Editor and Advocate specialising in tax law with a focus on legal research, case law analysis and tax litigation developments.
