The threat of a sudden exodus of foreign capital is a possibility | Photo Credit: RAGHUNATHAN SR
FPIs pulling out money, worsening current account deficit, and hawkish stance by central banks could run down the forex reserves
India’s external sector is facing serious challenges. As a net importer of oil and other commodities, India traditionally faces a balance of trade problem whenever oil and commodity prices go up. This time is not different. For the third quarter of 2021-22, India’s current account deficit (CAD) has reached $23 billion, which is a nine-year high. India’s exports are doing well, but as imports are growing faster, widening of the trade deficit is likely in the near term.
To make it worse, foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) have pulled out a significant amount of money from the Indian capital market over the last six months. It is believed that the imminent interest rate hike in the US is one possible reason behind this sustained withdrawal of FPIs from the Indian market.
An overall pessimistic global outlook on growth, continued uncertainty with geopolitics, and Covid related worries are adding to the pressure. The RBI recently highlighted that external sector vulnerability has increased significantly in the last few months.
Though the RBI has managed to control the volatility of the rupee until now, the external sector is facing pressures both in the current and the capital accounts. India has a chronic current account deficit problem, and mainly owing to the external factors mentioned above, the deficit is growing. Over the years, high capital inflows have allowed India to finance its CAD and build up a sizeable foreign exchange reserve. However, this equilibrium has got disturbed in the last six months as pressures are building up on the balance of payments front.
Foreign portfolio capital flows, which are a large component of foreign investment in India, have turned negative in a big way. FPIs have been net sellers every month from October 2021 to March 2022, resulting in a total outflow of $21.5 billion in just six months. To put this number in perspective, in the last 20 years, the highest FPI outflow from India was in 2008-09, and the net outflow was around $9.8 billion.
India also receives a huge amount of foreign direct investment (FDI), and it has been a steady source of capital to the country. FDI includes capital flows to listed and unlisted companies and private equity/venture capital (PE/VC) funding. In the last two years, India’s growing startup ecosystem has attracted a high volume of funding through the PE/VC route.
Data for 2021 shows that of the $55 billion of FDI, PE/VC funding accounted for around $35 billion. These strong inflows kept India’s overall external balance at a comfortable position. But in the last few months, there are indications that PE/VC inflows are slowing down. As per an IVCA-EY report dated April 12, pure-play PE/VC investments were $14 billion in January-March 2022, 36 per cent lower than in October-December 2021.
As per RBI data, the cumulative foreign investment inflows during April-February 2021-22 were only $24.6 billion against a much higher $80.1 billion during corresponding year-ago period. In a period of worsening CAD, a steady exodus of FPIs and a dwindling inflow of PE/VC funds pose a challenge for maintaining India’s overall external balance.
A combination of these unfavourable economic factors has led to a sharp decline in forex reserves. India has lost around $30 billion worth of forex reserves during the last three months. Weekly data of the RBI shows that the country’s total forex reserves have come down from around $633 billion on February 18, to around $604 billion on April 15. Although a part of the outflow was for settlement of a few forex sell-buy swaps undertaken by the RBI in the previous years, this erosion of reserves has raised some worries about India’s external stability.
There is a feeling that with more than $600 billion still in its coffers, India is well protected from external threats and vulnerabilities. It is indeed true that India is one of the top 10 countries with the highest foreign exchange reserves (Table).
However, India is somewhat of an outlier among these countries because most others in the top 10 are current account surplus countries.
In fact, if one leaves out the US, India is the only net-commodity importing, current account deficit country on the list. This essentially implies that India’s forex reserves are structurally different from other countries as it is made up entirely of liabilities, namely the foreign capital inflows. This makes India’s forex reserves more vulnerable to the threat of a sudden exodus of foreign capital.
A regime of tightening global liquidity and possible hawkish moves by the global central banks can trigger more capital outflows. India faced this problem during the ‘taper tantrum’ of 2013 and possibly will face it again. In such a scenario, the RBI may have to aggressively intervene in the foreign exchange market to control any undue short-term volatility of the rupee.
The forex reserves will be an essential policy tool for achieving external stability in such an eventuality. Over the years, India has incurred significant opportunity costs by holding its forex reserves in relatively low-yield, liquid assets. This opportunity cost is an insurance premium that India has paid to mitigate the threat associated with increased integration with global trade and finance. Possibly the time will soon come to evaluate how adequate this insurance cover is when the going gets really tough.
Pal is Professor of Economics at IIM Calcutta, Dutta is an independent analyst
Published on May 03, 2022