Setting precedents – The Hindu BusinessLine

Clipped from:

The Tata-Mistry ruling flags critical issues in governance, minority rights in private companies

Post the Supreme Court (SC) verdict in the Tata-Mistry case the focus is all on Cyrus Mistry and his options ahead. But this judgement also sets important precedents on questions of law relating to what constitutes minority shareholder oppression, their proportional representation on company Boards, governance as it applies to public versus private companies and the fiduciary duties of directors. These mustn’t fly under the radar. In its order, the SC has restricted itself mainly to questions of law raised by these appeals, taking the view that as the NCLT has already gone into the governance issues flagged by the Mistry camp (such as the Corus buy, Nano failure and transactions with the Sterling group), it had no reason to intervene in these ‘business decisions’.

The contentious part of the judgment comes where the Court held that representatives of the Tata Trusts — being philanthropic organisations with a 66 per cent stake in Tata Sons — were well within their rights to exercise affirmative votes and also put their fiduciary duties to their Trusts ahead of those to the company whilst voting on affairs concerning Tata Sons. Of course, every shareholder with a board seat has fiduciary duties to the organisation he represents but how can they assume precedence over the interests of the company? Don’t the interests have to be aligned? Isn’t a well-governed and run company important to the interests of the shareholder, irrespective of whether he represents a trust or a private equity investor? And what if the shareholder’s interests run counter to the best interests of the company? These are troubling questions that need to be answered by legal minds in the days ahead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s